The Rating System
The custom rating system scores films out of 100 points, carefully weighing the key elements that combine to create great cinema. Each component is ranked based on its subjective importance, aiming to ensure a balanced evaluation out of 5 stars, and in one sentence.
Writing
25
Strong writing is the foundation of any great film, encompassing character development, dialogue, plot structure, and thematic depth.
7
Characters
Assesses the depth and complexity of the characters. Are they well-developed with clear motivations, flaws, and growth?
6
Dialogue
Evaluates how authentic and impactful the dialogue feels. Does it sound natural and true to the characters while advancing the plot?
10
Plot & Action
Scores the strength of the story structure and pacing. Does the plot engage the audience, and do the action sequences feel integrated with the narrative?
2
Messaging
Measures the film’s ability to communicate a clear message or subtext, whether direct or implied.
25
Directing
20
Directing shapes the overall vision and tone of a film, influencing performances and visual cohesion.
6
Casting
Rates how well the actors fit their roles and bring depth to their characters.
7
Vision
Evaluates the clarity and consistency of the director’s creative vision.
7
Tone
Assesses how well the film maintains a consistent emotional atmosphere aligned with its narrative.
20
Acting
15
Great performances make characters feel real and emotionally engaging.
6
Delivery
Scores the authenticity and impact of the actors’ line delivery and emotional expression.
5
Chemistry
Measures how believable and compelling the relationships between characters feel.
4
Range
Assesses the actors’ ability to portray a wide range of emotions and adapt to different scenes.
15
Cinematography
10
Cinematography defines the visual language of a film, influencing mood and storytelling.
6
Mood
Evaluates how effectively camera work, lighting, and framing create the film’s emotional tone.
4
Inventiveness
Measures the creativity and originality of the cinematography. Does it avoid clichés and present a fresh visual style?
10
Production Design
10
Strong production design builds a believable and visually compelling world.
3
Set
Rates the authenticity and detail of the film’s set design.
4
Hair & Makeup
Evaluates how well hair and makeup reflect the characters’ personalities and the film’s setting.
3
Wardrobe
Scores the effectiveness of costume choices in supporting character and narrative.
10
Sound
10
Sound enhances the emotional and immersive qualities of a film.
6
Music & Score
Evaluates how well the score complements the film’s tone and emotional beats.
4
Sound Design
Assesses the quality and balance of sound effects, dialogue, and environmental audio.
10
Editing
10
Good editing controls the flow and structure of a film, ensuring a smooth and engaging experience.
4
Pacing
Scores how well the editing maintains a natural and engaging rhythm.
4
Structure
Evaluates the clarity and cohesion of the film’s narrative organization.
3
Style
Measures the creativity and effectiveness of editing techniques like transitions and cuts.
10